How should Beethoven be played?
How did Ludwig van
want his music to sound?
And what responsibility does the artist have
in interpreting a composer's works?
These are some of the questions
that were running through my head
as I listened to
Till Fellner at The Austrian Embassy
earlier this evening.
Till is in the midst of presenting all of the Beethoven Sonatas
and tonight he performed
No. 9, 10, 8, 11, & 26.
As I listened to him perform
the words
clarity,
and purity
came to mind.
Till played with a firm and gentle purpose.
With a calculated and calibrated precision.
The concert was beautiful
and
Mr. Fellner is obviously very, very talented.
BUT is this the way to play Beethoven?
When I think of Beethoven
I often think of
forceful playing,
spontaneity,
capriciousness,
and music that might teeter on the brink.
There was little if any of that this evening.
I really have loved Fellner's recordings of Bach's
Well-Tempered Clavier
and
Inventionen und Sinfonien
and feel that his approach is better suited to this composer.
I think his style might work well with Brahms
and look forward to hearing that in the future.
and look forward to hearing that in the future.
Interesting question! I tell my students that you should play what the composer wrote first, then interpret, if you wish. Not much of a tightrope to walk there... My favorite musical disalignment was Glenn Gould playing Mozart in the dry and hopeless way that so many others play Bach. Also, myself playing Bach's Prelude in C# minor with an almost Chopinian romanticism. For me, the question is - does it work? And of course, the answer changes from one set of ears to the next. I personally prefer my Beethoven nearly raw.
ReplyDeleteHello Cinch,
ReplyDeleteThanks for stopping by and for chiming in. As I said, Till's playing was really good BUT I think you & I agree that Beethoven should be played with a bit more abandon.
Best,
David
Such beautiful descriptions, I would love to go on a music history tour of Europe!
ReplyDeleteHello Patty,
ReplyDeleteThanks for stopping by. I'm glad you enjoyed it. A music history tour of Europe would be fun. Usually when I travel I do pay a lot of attention to music, going to concerts and composers' homes etc... I visited Sibelius's home when I was in Helsinki. Would love to go to Grieg's home as well as Chopin's. One of these days.
Best,
David
David, I'll be sure to call you to help identify my next anonymous classical earworm!
ReplyDeleteHello Willow,
ReplyDeletePlease do. I'd love to chat with you. I hope things are going well enough at your house.
Best,
David
I love beethoven! His music is incredible
ReplyDelete